Top Three Popular Posts

Showing posts with label Legality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Legality. Show all posts

Wednesday, 12 August 2026

For Smoking, the Street is an Open Space, not a Public Place

About nine years ago, after dinner at a restaurant late one night, I was standing with a few friends on the street outside, waiting for the cabs that they had booked to take them home. A police patrol came by, and one of the police officers approached one of my friends who was smoking and demanded that he pay a fine for smoking in a public place. I pointed out to the police officer that there were other people around us standing and smoking as well. The police officer got irritated and started yelling at me. We got into an argument, and I was taken into police custody and released the next morning. I forgot about the whole matter until, about a year later, I received a summons to appear in court for a FIR filed against me by the police. There were three charges against me - disturbing the public peace, obstructing a police officer on duty, and insulting the modesty of a woman through words or gestures (the police officer administering the fine being a female). 

I knew the charges were false since I was there in person at the time of the incident. I went through the FIR and the accompanying witness written statements and saw flaws in the evidence. I looked up The Cigarettes and Other Tobacco Products (Prohibition of Advertisement and Regulation of Trade and Commerce, Production, Supply and Distribution) Act, 2003 or the COPTA Act as it is known in short. Sec 3(L) of the COPTA Act 2003 states that '"public place" means any place which the public have access, whether as of right or not, and includes auditorium, hospital buildings, railway waiting room, amusement centers, restaurants, public offices, court buildings, educational institutions, libraries, public conveyances and the like which are visited by general public but does not include any open space;' The definition of what constitutes a public place, according to the COPTA Act, where the police have jurisdiction to impose fines on smokers, gives clear examples of what constitutes a public place, and nowhere does it state that the street falls into this category. It is essentially what is defined in the Act as an 'open space'. I decided that I would not employ a lawyer and would defend myself as a party-in-person for a number of reasons, including: my personal interest in seeing where the police and judiciary wanted to go with this matter, my financial situation, and the fact that these charges were false. I appeared in court and pleaded not guilty of the charges against me. The case was posted for trial. The prosecution listed seven witnesses - three police officers, 3 staff from the restaurant outside which the incident happened and an unknown seventh witness. The three police officers were the female police officer (a police sub-inspector who was the complainant), a head constable who had accompanied her, and the station house office of the police station that I was detained in. The three restaurant staff were two employees working in the restaurant at the time of the incident, and a day manager who came to work the next morning after the incident.

The case was called for hearing for a total of about sixty times spread over nearly eight years. It was even called for hearing during the fake Covid 19 pandemic. I attended court for every single hearing. During the fake pandemic, I was not allowed inside the court premises despite my stating that I was the accused as party-in-person. The court officials demanded that I produce an advocate identification for entry. In the sixty-odd hearings that were called, the complainant turned up about 2-3 times. Out of the list of seven prosecution witnesses, finally only three appeared in court to give evidence - the complainant herself, the station house officer and the day manager of the restaurant. I cross-examined both the complainant and the station house officer and asked them whether, according to the COPTA Act, the street was a public place or an open space. Both the complainant and station house officer stated that it was a public place. I read out to them the definition of a public place, as per the COPTA Act. I pointed out that the street was nowhere listed as a public place, but falls in the category of open space, outside the jurisdiction of the police for administering a fine according to the COPTA Act. The officers insisted that the street was a public place without any supporting material, other than what appears to be their personal opinions.

Finally, after the prosecution witnesses had given their evidence, since I did not call upon any defense witnesses, I was asked to give a statement in court, as the accused, under Section 313 of the CrPC. I prepared a written statement and submitted it in court. Besides pointing out the flaws in the statements and evidence of the police officers directly related to the charged filed against me, my written statement under Section 313 of the CrPC included the following section regarding the COPTA Act 2003:


3. THE COPTA ACT 2003


Now, this brings me to the most important aspect of the police action against me. When I looked up the The Cigarettes and Other Tobacco Products Act (Prohibition of Advertisement and Regulation of Trade and Commerce, Production, Supply and Distribution) Act 2003, or COPTA Act 2003, I found that the entire police action at the time of the incident - of fining an individual for smoking on the street - is illegal and outside their jurisdiction. Not only this, but wherever in India the police are stopping a person standing or walking down a street smoking a cigarette, beedi, cigar, etc., they are committing an illegal action outside their ambit and, essentially, extorting money from the public. This action is mostly targeted at the middle- and low-income classes. I think it would be rare to see a police officer walk up to an Adani or Ambani, or a politician, or a senior police officer, or even a judge of the judiciary and impose a COPTA fine on him, if they saw him standing on the street with a cigarette.

COPTA is an Act aimed at protecting the general public from tobacco harms. COPTA is mainly directed at the supply chain of tobacco to regulate it and control tobacco use. The focus of the COPTA Act 2003, which has 33 sections, is first the producers and distributors of tobacco products, and then, the consumers. In terms of its relevance to the general public, i.e. with consumption or, specifically smoking tobacco, the regulatory aspects are to be implemented by law enforcement in public places, such as railway stations, government offices, libraries, public conveyances, etc., where the public generally gathers, in close proximity of about one or two feet, standing together for some moments in time for a common purpose, constrained and separated from open spaces by the boundaries of the public place. In an open space, people are passing each other momentarily, as it happens with people walking on the street, or any other open space. Even if they are standing together, each person is free to move further away into the open space as he or she wishes. The person is not constrained in movement, like it is in a public place. In order to not infringe upon the fundamental rights of an individual, which include the right of a smoker to smoke a product that is approved by the government and legally sold in retail outlets, Sec 3(L) of the COPTA Act 2003 states that '"public place" means any place which the public have access, whether as of right or not, and includes auditorium, hospital buildings, railway waiting room, amusement centers, restaurants, public offices, court buildings, educational institutions, libraries, public conveyances and the like which are visited by general public but does not include any open space;' The phrase 'but does not include any open space' is a key part of the definition of what a public place is. It is also a key part that recognizes the rights of an individual to freely smoke legal products in an open space. If this phrase was not present, then, effectively, the individual can only smoke in private places, such as homes. Such a rule would mean that the individual is literally confined to a small part of his rightful free space in this world, further impinging on his freedom. Those creating such laws in the name of protecting public health may have been aware that restricting people to only private places for smoking would amplify the exposure of others in the private places, including children, women and elders. In fact, this concern for people in private spaces is one of the precise reasons why a person steps out into the street, or any other open space, to have a smoke. The policymakers may have also included this phrase knowing the impossibility of preventing people from smoking in open spaces ,which make up most of the planet's surface. If the phrase 'does not include any open space' was not included in the COPTA definition of what a public place is, effectively lawmakers and society would be saying that there is no place for a smoker in this world. 

Smoking is a human trait. It is one of the earliest distinguishers of the human species branching out from the primate species. Possibly, the discovery of fire was soon followed by the discovery of smoking. Smoking is one of the methods of administering medicine in Ayurveda's panchakarma process for detoxifying and restoring balance to the body and mind. People have smoked for tens of thousands of years. They have mostly smoked plants and herbs much less toxic than tobacco, like cannabis for example, which is highly medicinal, especially to relieve stress, anxiety, fatigue, for digestion, etc.. In colonial times, in order for the British businessmen and politicians to become rich from their tobacco businesses, and in order to make more revenue, the government took away cannabis - the medicine and intoxicant of the poorest castes and classes of Indian society and the spiritual herb of the sadhus of all religions - and replaced it with the vastly more harmful tobacco. So today, while on the one hand the government earns a very significant chunk of its revenue from tobacco and constantly increases the taxation of tobacco products, on the other hand, it implements policies such as the COPTA Act 2003 that not only ensure it gets its revenue from tobacco but also enables it to take penal action against the individual for consuming the very same product that the government vastly profits the most from, by stating that the product is harmful for public health. The poor indigent smoker - who makes up a significant proportion of the people this country - over time has had his medicinal cannabis replaced with harmful tobacco, has had to pay increasingly high prices for the tobacco, and has also got penalized for smoking the tobacco. Is there anything such as the fundamental rights of a smoker to life, liberty, equality, justice and good health? When we talk about a smoker we are talking about Albert Einstein, Winston Churchill, Jawaharlal Nehru, Satyajit Ray, Che Guevara, etc., here, as much as we are talking about the poor indigent common man. However, for the smoker belonging to the upper classes of society all this pain, suffering and discrimination is mostly invisible. The upper class smoker still gets his cannabis from the black market, buys the most expensive tobacco at the highest price without feeling the slightest pinch on his pocket from the ever-increasing prices, and never ever pays a COPTA fine. It is always the poor working class man or mendicant, standing in some discrete corner of the street, trying to get some relief from the pain and toil of surviving in this brutal world with a smoke for a few moments, who is the main target for this extortion. The newspapers state that lakhs of people are fined every year for COPTA violations by the police in India and I am positive that a majority of these are fines imposed by the police of members of the public, who are standing or walking on the street and smoking in open spaces that are outside police jurisdiction for imposing COPTA fines. 

In addition to the COPTA definition of what constitutes a public place, the Guidelines for Law Enforcers for effective implementation of Tobacco Control Laws 2013, published by the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Government of India, defines a public place as '“public place” means any place to which the public have access, whether as of right or not, and includes auditorium, hospital buildings, railway waiting room, amusement centres, restaurants, public offices, court buildings, educational institutions, libraries, public conveyances and the like which are visited by general public but does not include any open space;'. Here, a few more examples of what constitutes a public place have been included, in addition to what is defined in COPTA Act 2003. But here also the very important phrase 'but does not include any open space' is present. Further, in Section 4 of the Guidelines, Rules relating to prohibition on smoking in public places (Section 4), it states that '(c) “Open space” mentioned in Section 3 (1) of the Act shall not include any place visited by the public such as open auditorium, stadium, railway station, bus stop/stand, and other such places. (d) “Public place” defined in Section 3 (1) of the Act shall also include work places, shopping malls, and cinema halls.' As we can see here, there is an even further clarity being provided as to what constitutes public places and open spaces. Please note that nowhere in the list of public places provided does the street find mention. The street outside the restaurant, 80 Feet Road, and the broad pavement that it includes, is very clearly an open space as per COPTA definitions. It is not a public place.

As a result of this legal matter, I decided to try and reach out to some legal experts on COPTA or those involved in anti-tobacco policy making in Karnataka, to see if they could throw more light on the matter of the street as an open space. I wrote to the Karnataka State Anti-Tobacco Control Cell. I did not receive any response from them. I wrote to Mr. XXXXX, asking for clarity on whether the street is an open space or public place. When I had searched the internet, his name appeared as an expert on tobacco control policies. Mr. XXXXX replied to my email saying he was not a lawyer.  In his own words, he has been engaged in public health research and policy related work as it concerns tobacco towards reducing tobacco use in society. He said that he was willing to assist in any possible way. He was the one who shared the Guidelines for Law Enforcers for effective implementation of Tobacco Control Laws 2013, published by the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Government of India. He said that on page 15 of the Guidelines document, the following further clarity was provided on public place and open space: '(b) “restaurant” shall mean any place to which the public has access and where any kind of food or drink is supplied for consumption on the premises by any person by way of business for consideration monetary or otherwise and shall include the open space surrounding such premises and includes- (i) Refreshment room, banquet halls, discotheques, canteen, coffee house, pubs, bar, airport lounge, and the like. (c) “Open space” mentioned in Section 3 (1) of the Act shall not include any place visited by the public such as open auditorium, stadium, railway station, bus stop/stand, and other such places." Mr. Bhojani stated that the phrase "and shall include the open space surrounding such premises" leaves room for interpretation, especially if there is a bus stop close to the restaurant. In this case, there is no bus stand nearby. There is a school, of course, but that has not stopped the shop outside Empire from selling tobacco products.
 
Now, when a law enforceable by penal action is left for interpretation, it is particularly worrisome. Who will interpret and how will they interpret? The restaurant's premises cannot be projected outwards in undefined directions, offering an umbrella for the police to harass a citizen. The open space surrounding the restaurant essentially includes the whole universe.

XXXXX Hotel does not have a smoking zone inside. There is no bus stop or other public place as designated by the COPTA Act close by on the broad pavement of  xxxxx Road outside. Some customers stand there in the open space and smoke for a few minutes as they wait for a cab or other friends. Other people are either entering or leaving the restaurant, or walking on the street. The shop attached to the restaurant is where cigarettes are sometimes purchased. If one wants to know the distance we were at from the entrance of XXXXX hotel when the incident took place, I would say that it was about 50 feet. My friend was standing near the edge of the footpath, waiting for his cab. So, is this outside the maximum limit of space that the phrase "and shall include the open space surrounding such premises" is referring to? Or does this inclusion of open space surrounding a restaurant depend on the distance of the police officer implementing COPTA from the hotel? Does wherever the smoker stand and smoke immediately become included in the "open space surrounding such premises"? What about standing on the terrace of the next building? Do private residents living next to restaurants become liable for COPTA action if they step out into their gardens to smoke?  

The COPTA Act 2003 by itself is quite clear. It appears that the Guidelines for Law Enforcers for effective implementation of Tobacco Control Laws 2013, published by the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Government of India, which introduced the additional phrase "and shall include the open space surrounding such premises" is a dilution of the COPTA Act and a transgression into the freedoms and liberties of the citizen.

We see everywhere shops and commercial establishments putting up No Smoking signs outside their establishments. No business establishment has the right to put up a No Smoking sign outside its premises. Its jurisdiction ends within its boundaries. What someone can do or cannot do outside its premises is beyond its jurisdiction. No Smoking signs should face inwards into these establishment and not outwards to the surrounding open spaces that make up the universe beyond it. If someone smokes inside the boundaries, violating smoking rules, then action can be taken by the owner or police and other such authorized persons. It is this projection by these commercial establishments into open spaces, working hand in hand with the police department, that creates the intrusions in the open space of the citizen who is a smoker.

There appears to be a massive lack of knowledge on the part of both law enforcement and the judiciary in the matter of public place and open space with regard to COPTA rules. I would like to think that it is ignorance and not a willful exploitation of the public using the loopholes in the law and the lack of knowledge among the public. It appears that the police department has decided on its own that even open spaces come under its jurisdiction and that the judiciary is supporting this invasion of fundamental rights. If the definition of what constitutes a public place or open space is not clear, and left to interpretation by individual members of the police department based on how they feel at the moment, then this can be used at will, as is being used at will, according to the whims and fancies of the enforcing police officer, resulting in cases of harassment of the public. 

As is obvious here, the lack of thought behind the dubious tobacco control measures taken in this country in the name of public health, including the COPTA Act, is one of the fundamental reasons why lakhs of Indians across India today are victims of police extortion and judicial harassment in the name of tobacco control. Almost all these victims are persons belonging to the lower and middle classes. As I stated earlier, this whole process - of prohibiting the medicinal cannabis to introduce the harmful tobacco in order for more profits and revenue, the increasing costs and regulations on tobacco, the legal harassment of the smoker, etc., - displays a complete disregard for one of the basic human rights of an individual. The error in thinking that smoking is harmful - which is at the root of the cannabis smoked as ganja is harmful and cannabis drunk as bhang is medicinal story - is a myth created by the Indian upper castes, working in conjunction with the British, in order to suppress the lower castes and classes, to take away their ganja from them and promote the more harmful tobacco. This is despite the fact that, as I stated earlier, smoking is one of the five methods of purifying the body and mind according to Ayurveda. The State needs to understand that humans have been smoking for tens of thousands of years and will continue to do so as long as the species exists. It is impossible for the State to stop a human who wishes to smoke from smoking. This lies in the area of liberty of the individual to choose what to consume. Yes, if the State wishes so much to protect public health, it can ensure that the most healthy medicinal herbs are available for the smoker. Completely legalize cannabis for all purposes, and within the space of a year, the State will achieve more reduction in tobacco use than decades of tobacco-control laws and policies have managed to achieve in this country. But then, it will drastically reduce one of the biggest sources of State revenue, tobacco. Therefore, the State along with the powerful tobacco lobby refuses to allow the re-introduction of cannabis. The State appears to be so ignorant of cannabis that it does not recognize that revenue from cannabis will exceed revenue from tobacco within a few years. Not only that, cumulatively, revenue from both cannabis and tobacco will significantly increase overall State revenue while at the same time improving public health and meeting tobacco control targets. Why is this not happening? Are the law makers, policy makers, judiciary, police and other entities making so much revenue from the tobacco industry and the criminal cases foisted on the people, in the name of tobacco control, that they do not want to let it happen? 

For those who have the head-in-the-sand kind of attitude that believes all smoking is harmful and would like to see tobacco, cannabis, and all other forms of human consumption of plants through smoking to cease, have you considered this...Besides this being a natural impossibility, even if all humans were completely banned from smoking, air pollution will still be one of the leading causes of death in India. This air pollution does not come from humans smoking tobacco or ganja, but from the billions of sources of fossil fuel emission, besides large-scale human actions like crop stubble burning. Overlooking all these gross injustices to public health, and targeting the individual tobacco smoker, who is not even smoking in a public place, shows some serious issues with our society today.

In this specific instance, I would go as far as stating that is a case of incorrect implementation of the COPTA Act. It is the police department that has disturbed the public peace, unlawfully fined a person of the public, as well as detained and initiated legal action against the accused. The question of obstructing a police officer on duty does not arise here as the police action itself is illegal. Thus, sections 186 and 504 of the IPC do not have any firm basis...


The judge, in his judgement acquitted me of the charges made against me by the police, stating that there was lack of evidence for conviction. Regarding the matter of whether the street is an open space or a public place, as per the COPTA Act, the judge wrote in his order that "in my considered opinion" the street is a public place. He, like the police officers, did not provide any evidence to back his opinion. Now, when the police and judiciary implement laws based on their personal opinions and personal interests, it is a serious concern for the citizen as the freedom enshrined in the Constitution becomes a matter of the personal opinions of these supposed protectors of the citizen and the Constitution.

Tuesday, 19 November 2024

At the Supreme Court of India for Ganja Legalization: Part IV: My Judgement


This is the concluding segment of the four-part documentation of my interaction with the Supreme Court of India for ganja and charas legalization that also had the previous three steps: the writ petition; the special leave petition; and the appeal against the Registrar's order.

As I said at the start of this whole exercise of going to the Supreme Court of India with a petition to legalize ganja and charas, some of my objectives were: to bring the matter to the attention of the apex judiciary that protects our fundamental rights; to understand the current thought process of the judiciary in this matter; through this, to bring more attention from a wider audience to this grossest of violation of fundamental rights in India for the last 150 years; to share the findings of the Indian Hemp Drugs Commission of 1894-95 which showed how much ganja and charas were, and are still, integral to India's social, economic, spiritual, medical, legal and environmental fabric; to show that the classes and castes most affected by cannabis prohibition are the poorest people of India for whom ganja and charas were a vital part of what constituted a healthy, content, wholesome life; to show that when ganja and charas were completely legal, without any regulatory curbs whatsoever, Indian society had thrived for thousands of years without any problems because of this; to show the myths and propaganda that have been perpetrated by the upper classes and castes to keep ganja and charas prohibited; to show the vast economic benefits of ganja and charas legalization; to show the classes of persons opposed to ganja and charas legalization; etc.

In the process of going to the judiciary, I think I achieved the above stated goals. 

Through the exercise, I found that the e-Filing option that has been introduced by the Supreme Court of India greatly improves the citizen's access to the highest judiciary. I found that the Supreme Court Registry worked smoothly and efficiently in assisting the citizen to package the matter and present it before the court. The main glitch I faced in terms of the processes was the accessibility and technology issues around attending hearings in virtual mode. Most people seem to fail to understand that more than half of India does not possess a smartphone, let alone a computer with good internet connectivity. Inclusivity, as a key criteria in designing systems, is still a long way off in this country. Almost everything that is thought about excludes the poorest citizens who make up the majority of this country. I do not know if there are any poor advocates who do not possess a smartphone or computer. The setting up of facilities - maybe in district courts - from where citizens can attend virtual court hearings for their matters in high courts and the Supreme Court will increase the accessibility of this mode of operation by the courts of law that is increasingly becoming an absolute necessity. 

The matter - through its being processed and brought before the judiciary - got at least some members of the judiciary to look at it. Even if they did not do the right thing - as of now - and restore the fundamental rights of hundreds of millions of Indians, including myself, it at least came to their attention. Judges Bela Trivedi, Aniruddha Bose and Satish Chandra Sharma became aware of at least some part of what was presented before them. Aniruddha Bose spent some time thinking about it and voicing his views on the matter. The Registrar, Pavanesh D, went through the special leave petition, and provided a good summary of it in his order dismissing the special leave petition. Satish Chandra Sharma announced to open court at least some part of what the petition intended to achieve.

From what I saw, the judiciary in India is still not up to speed on a matter in which apex courts like the South African Constitutional Court and the Mexican Supreme Court already made the right ruling more than three years ago. The Supreme Court of India seems to be behind the times - as is the case with most law courts in the world - when it comes to the cannabis resurgence that is happening globally. The judges of these courts seem to come from an entirely different era than that of the vast majority of young and middle aged people who now live on this planet. The effectiveness of the propaganda created by the upper castes and classes over the last 150 years is evident in the mindset of the judiciary. The complete irrationality of ganja and charas prohibition given the widespread evidence of its usage and relative harmlessness for thousands of years reveal the backward mindset of the judiciary in this matter. This irrationality is evident in: the complete unscientific nature of a plant being considered illegal just because it contains more than an arbitrarily set limit of 0.3% for the most medicinal and beneficial cannabis compound - delta9-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC); the complete irrationality of considering a plant legal if it is drunk (as bhang) but illegal if it is smoked (as ganja or charas) just because the upper classes and castes prefer to drink it rather than smoke it; the complete disregard for the widespread scientific evidence of benefits of cannabis emerging from the US, Canada, Europe and other so-called developed nations; the complete disregard of the oppression of the poorer classes due to ganja and charas prohibition; and so on. According to the Indian drug terminology, bhang is the leaves of the cannabis plant while ganja is the flowers and charas is the resin. Bhang and the seeds are legal whereas the flowers and the resin is illegal. This system of separating what is legal and what is illegal is based on the 1961 UN Single Convention Treaty, and is completely different from what western societies use to define what is legal and what is illegal. In the west, cannabis with less than 0.3% delta9-tetrahydrocannabinal (THC) is legal, while cannabis with THC greater than 0.3% is illegal. This is irrespective of whether it is the leaves, flowers or resin. Both these criteria are equally absurd. For one thing, people who claim to drink bhang most definitely consume the flowers and resin along with the leaves. With regard to the 0.3% THC limit, there is no scientific basis for this limit, it has been arbitrarily set. THC is the most medicinal and beneficial compound in cannabis. None of all this has however stopped law and drug enforcement from cutting down a cannabis plant wherever they see it, whether it is a sapling, or a plant bearing only leaves. The persons found growing these plants have been arrested and charged with crimes according to the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act of 1985...These persons arrested are most often from the poorer classes...The upper classes and castes procure and consume their ganja and charas with impunity from the black market at high costs. They drink it as bhang in their religious and social occasions. Obviously, they seem to have connections that are beyond the means of the common man.

This is especially chagrining for India, since no other country in the world has the kind of cannabis culture India had, and still has. It is disappointing that the apex court does not recognize: the harms of ganja and charas prohibition to the majority of India's people - its poorest - who are denied a safe intoxicant and universal medicine; the overall harms to society that continued prohibition is causing, especially through the misuse and abuse of alcohol, tobacco, opioids, synthetic legal and illegal pharmaceutical drugs; the potential of cannabis to provide affordable universal healthcare; the urgency of the climate problem that has been caused by the fossil fuel, construction, synthetic fibers, petrochemical-based plastics, chemical fertilizer and pesticide industries who thrive in the absence of cannabis; the class and caste system that is behind prohibition and the blatant discrimination against large sections of the population that ganja and charas prohibition is; the spiritual importance of ganja and charas as entheogen for Indian society; the opportunity to rid the system of the evils of the black market for ganja and the extortion that law enforcement and excise thrive on; and so on...

The understanding that ganja and charas prohibition is, first and foremost, a class and caste issue continues to elude Indian society at large. Even the poorest classes and castes - who are the most affected by this prohibition - seem to not understand that it is a method for the upper classes and castes to subjugate and oppress the lower classes and castes. Not only does it render the working classes and outcasts unhealthy, it also builds dependency in them on the drugs that the higher classes sell to get richer - alcohol, tobacco, opioids and synthetic pharmaceutical drugs. The anti-ganja propaganda has been so strong and effective that most of the poorer classes themselves believe it to be evil and harmful, and alcohol and tobacco to be harmless. Certain sections of the working and poorer classes still do get access to ganja (rarely charas) but it is only for those who are willing to take the risk of losing their jobs or imprisonment and for those who can access and afford the ganja. The rich upper classes and castes have fooled the whole of Indian society by saying that bhang and ganja are two different drugs. By themselves giving sanction for bhang as permitted for religious usage, the priests of the religions of the upper classes and castes - and through them the kings and businessmen - consume cannabis with impunity. According to the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act of 1985, cannabis as bhang is legal. What does this legality mean? Can any person grow as much bhang as he wishes and use it for any purpose that he wishes? Why, then, is the cannabis plant seized and a human arrested when it is grown or found in someone's possession? If permissions are required for people to grow and consume bhang, where are these permissions?  Who has given permission, and to whom, to consume cannabis as bhang? How can a person procure bhang if he says it is for religious use? Can any person procure bhang saying that it is for religious use? Which are the religions that have been given sanction for the consumption of bhang and how? Why are only some religions given sanction, if any sanction has been given at all? The answers to all these questions, and many more, will reveal that by calling cannabis 'bhang' when the upper classes and castes drink it, and 'ganja' or 'charas' when the lower classes and castes smoke it, the ruling upper classes and castes have created a means of discriminating against both the cannabis plant and the users who wish to smoke it rather than drink it (often because of the simple reason that the poorer classes cannot afford the milk, nuts and spices that the upper classes and castes use to prepare their bhang). All this legality of bhang and sanctions as per law are myths that the upper classes and castes use as convenient to condone their usage and punish others. As I stated elsewhere, the upper classes and castes procure cannabis through the poor members of the working class whom they employ. These workers often go back to their villages and hometowns and bring the cannabis for their masters to use as they please. If the worker is caught along the way by police or excise, the employer will wash his hands of all knowledge of the matter. The same employer will also fire the worker if he finds him smoking the same cannabis as ganja. 

In this instance, I decided to go solo - as the individual citizen seeking restoration of his fundamental rights - through a mandamus writ petition. I wanted to take this option as far as I could. The Supreme Court and its Registry rejected this path and nudged me to take the legislature and Public Interest Litigation (PIL) routes. In each of these routes, what is emphasized is the large number of people - hundreds of millions - who are affected by ganja and charas prohibition. I like to speak for myself, so I do not see myself filing PILs on behalf of other people. Nor do I see myself lobbying the legislature to make the corrections to the NDPS laws. For trying to effect the required changes through these paths, I leave it to some people from the rest of the hundreds of millions who understand the importance of this and wish to influence positive societal changes. I sincerely wish that large numbers of persons come forward and exert pressure on the judiciary and legislature by filing PILs, talking to their representatives, and themselves filing similar writ petitions. The whole idea of sharing all this information through the blog is so that it will prove useful to anybody who wishes to do impactful work in these areas. The contents of the writ petition Diary Number 23878 of 2023 can be easily shaped into a PIL with minimum modifications. Anybody is free to do so...

What worries me the most about the stance of the judiciary is that its integrity appears to be compromised, leaning towards the upper class-upper caste government that favors the rich industries that are most opposed to ganja and charas legalization, and who benefit the most from its prohibition. The reluctance to initiate positive action in this matter seems to indicate that the same upper class and caste mentality that pervades government and industry in India also pervades the Supreme Court of India. I also get the impression that there is great pressure on the Supreme Court from these forces operating from outside and within to protect the evils of the current system. For a court of law - especially one that is established by the people to protect their fundamental rights and freedoms - integrity and credibility are the most important requirements. If integrity and credibility are lost, then the power that the court holds is lost, because this power has been given to it by the people. The court then becomes just another government department, routinely processing petty and trivial matters that are best left to the lower courts of justice. The people will go elsewhere looking for justice, or even start taking matters into their own hands, until a point is reached where the entire existing structure, including the judiciary, are rendered symbolic but hold no real value in the eyes of the citizen, much like the President of India is today. 

Every citizen is a judge in the court of his or her own mind. Every person judges and is, in turn, judged. In my court, I find that the representatives of the Supreme Court of India - Bela Trivedi, Aniruddha Bose and Satish Chandra Sharma, and the Registrar Pavanesh D - failed in executing their responsibilities of protecting and upholding the fundamental rights of the citizen as enshrined in the Constitution of India. I gave them three opportunities to do so, but they failed...I will follow whatever path I think is necessary to exist in the freedom that is mine as the eternal spirit...I legalized ganja a long time ago...I was only asking the State to do the same so that the suffering of hundreds of millions of Indians and of the natural world - with its numerous living beings - that makes up this country called India, can be reduced rather than increased...That, my dear friends and foes, was the documentation of my visit to the Supreme Court of India for ganja and charas legalization...

Monday, 11 November 2024

At the Supreme Court of India for Ganja Legalization: Part III: The Appeal


As I wrote in Part II, I received an email from the Registry in the third week of May 2024 with the Registrar's order dated 31-Jan-2024 dismissing the special leave petition Diary Number 3847 of 2024.

I decided to appeal the Registrar's order. I prepared a review petition and uploaded it on the e-Filing site. The Registry informed me that a Miscellaneous Application appealing the Registrar's order is what needs to be submitted, and not a review petition. So, I prepared a Miscellaneous Application to appeal the order.

In the Miscellaneous Application (MA), I put down in writing more or less what had transpired between the Registry and myself in the course of preparing the special leave petition (SLP). I wrote that I had prepared the SLP based on the Status/Stage and Disposal Type of the Writ Petition Diary Number 23878 of 2023, which stated 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed'. I wrote that on repeated requests for the Registry to clarify where in the Supreme Court Rules 2013 it said that one could not file an appeal against a Supreme Court order, especially given the information in the Disposal Type of the writ petition, I did not receive any reply or clarification. I also stated in the appeal that Article 136 of the Indian Constitution said, '136.(1) Notwithstanding anything in this Chapter, the Supreme Court may, in its discretion, grant special leave to appeal from any judgement, decree, determination, sentence or order in any cause or matter passed or made by any court or tribunal in the territory of India', and that this, to me, was clearly a case of the Supreme Court granting me permission to file a special leave petition. I appealed that, in the light of all this, the Registrar's order be relooked at.

The Registry interacted with me, and I corrected the defects raised in the document and submitted it along with an application to condone delay and another to appear and argue in person. The Miscellaneous Application (MA) was processed and given a Diary Number - 27735 of 2024 - in July. The status of the MA was set to 'Pending Scrutiny' in the e-Filing website.

I traveled to Kerala to my ancestral house in the first week of September as a part of my routine to clear the place of weeds that grow wild during the monsoons. Until recently, internet and phone connectivity had been very poor at this place. However, in the last few months a new network tower by my service provider had come up close to where I lived. I carried my laptop on this visit and found that the internet connection was now good, and I could access my email. 

In the third week of September, when I was in Kerala, I received a notification from the Registry saying that the MA was to be listed on 23rd September 2024, in about three days' time. It was to be listed in Court No. 13 as Item Number 18. The presiding judges would be Bela Trivedi and Satish Chandra Sharma. I did not have enough money to take a flight to New Delhi and pay for accommodation, and there was not enough time to travel by train, even if I was able to get tickets, that is. So, I wrote to the Registry stating that I still faced the same challenges as when I had interacted with the Registrar in September 2023 for the writ petition. I still did not have a smartphone, and my laptop still had the same minimal configurations that were not conducive for a video conferencing. I asked if there were any places around where I was staying in Kerala - such as the District Courts or the Kerala High Court - where I could avail of a video conferencing facility to be present in the hearing. I asked if the hearing would happen in my absence. The Registry replied that I have only two ways of attending the hearing - either physically or through virtual mode - and sent me a notice to attend the hearing. 

I scouted around my place in Kerala to see if there were any internet cafes from where I could attend the hearing. I hardly found any, as, obviously, the smartphone has made the internet cafe nearly extinct. The ones I found were more or less non-functional. So, I decided that I had no choice but to attend the hearing by logging into the video conference using my substandard laptop. On the day of the hearing, 23rd September 2024, I logged into the video conference using the URL shared by the Supreme Court. I could see the court being prepared for the day's hearings. I tested the speaker and microphone and found them to be working satisfactorily. The internet connectivity was good as well. I noticed that there were no chat features appearing in the video conferencing application. The time was around 10.00am with the hearing scheduled to start at 10.30am. I sat back to wait and looked up to see that I had been removed from the video conference. A message flashed on the screen saying that the host/moderator had removed me from the video call. I tried to log in again but now got the message that the host had prevented access to the video conference. For about the next one hour, I kept trying to get into the hearing in virtual mode but was denied access. In between, I wrote to the Registry stating that I was being denied access. Finally, I gave up trying to get in and switched off the computer.



Later in the evening, I checked the Supreme Court website and found that there are contact numbers of moderators and court masters for each court published on the day of the hearing. I found a court order had been uploaded against the Case Details of M.A. 27735 of 2024. It said '1. Party is not present when the matter is called out. 2. By way of last opportunity, list the matter on 27.09.2024 (Friday).' 

I wrote a letter to the Registry and to the Supreme Court Legal Services Committee (SCLSC) stating that I was having access issues, and if it would be possible to have an amicus curiae for the hearing on Friday the 27th of September.

I was heading back to Bengaluru anyway in the next couple of days. Even though the internet connection at home in Bengaluru was much worse than what it was in Kerala, at least there would be more options for attending the hearing in virtual mode from Bengaluru.  When I reached Bengaluru on Thursday, 26th September 2024, I scouted around for co-working spaces to see if any of them could provide me with a computer along with the typical cubicle and internet connectivity that they provided as services. None of them provided computers. You had to bring your own machine and avail of the services there. I found a laptop service center that hired out used laptops near my home and asked them if they would loan me a laptop for a day for the next day's hearing. They refused, stating that they only hired out laptops to corporate accounts and not to individuals. I asked them if they could upgrade my existing laptop from Windows 8.1 to a higher version OS. They said that they could do it. When I checked with them three hours later, I found that the upgrade was not working, since in the first place the existing configuration of my laptop itself did not have enough processor speed and memory to run a higher version of Windows. Seeing my predicament, the service center personnel were kind enough to lend me a laptop for the next day's hearing.

On the next day, 27th September 2024, I went to a co-working space and booked a room for four hours. I logged into the virtual hearing at around 10.00am. The chat features of the video conferencing application were visible now. The video was working fine. I tested for audio and found that the speakers were working fine, but the microphone was not audible. I immediately called the service center and they once more showed great consideration by sending a replacement laptop that I used to log into the video conference once again. By now, court was in progress. I tested the audio of the replacement laptop and again found that the speakers seemed to be working fine but the microphone was not audible. It was too late now to do anything. I also thought that maybe the host or moderator may have disabled the microphone, and that it might be turned on when my item was called out. I asked the host through the chat facility which item was currently in progress, and found that my item was still a long way off. 

I watched the court proceedings as it unfolded. Bela Trivedi was in the driver's seat, skillfully dealing with murder, dowry, divorce and financial fraud cases, and imposing costs on petitioners. Satish Chandra Sharma was taking the back seat, and making occasional observations like "They are finding it difficult to address us as Honorable Judges...It is fine if you don't address us as anything..." and "She was burnt alive, mind you!" I noticed that those who argued more with the judges got more time with them, and even if the judges initially tried to dismiss the petition, they started listening when the petitioner persisted. It appears that a hearing in the Supreme Court is more suited for those who are better talkers than listeners. So, even if a person puts down the most crisp, compelling petition in writing, finally at the end of the day it is how they speak with the judges that seems to matter much more than what has been submitted in writing. If one is not much of a talker, then he or she will struggle to have dialogues with the judges. Advocates who are hesitant speakers will probably quickly learn the ropes and start to become more vocal if they want to succeed. The louder and more you shout, the more likely you are to be heard, is the impression I got from the proceedings...

When my Item Number 45 came up, the host/moderator unmuted my microphone in the virtual hearing. 

"Please see page 2 of the appeal which shows the screenshot of the Case Details for writ petition Diary Number 23878 of 2023 with the Disposal Type as 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed'. It is on the basis of this that I have filed the special leave petition", I leant forward and said,

"You are not audible. Please unmute the mike", I received a message on the chat from the host/moderator. 

I again repeated what I said.

"We cannot hear you", the judges said.

Well, I thought, that is that...So much for presenting my side of the story in the hearing...

"This person had filed a writ petition earlier which was dismissed. Now he has filed this appeal", said Bela Trivedi to Satish Chandra Sharma.

"Impose costs", I think I heard Satish Chandra Sharma say.

"Some person, who claims to be the petitioner has appeared on the video call", Bela Trivedi was, by now, dictating to the court clerk.

When I had read up the general protocol for attending virtual hearings, it said that, on entering the virtual hearing, petitioners/respondents were to identify themselves by holding up their identification document against the web camera. When I got into the web conference, I was not asked by the host/moderator to identify myself. Instead, he/she asked me through the chat facility what my name and item number were and said that he/she would be updating my name in the virtual call to appear as '45. Koshy T Abraham' and this is how it now appeared for all to see. But Bela Trivedi had her doubts about my authenticity. So, I pulled out my driver's license from my wallet and held it in front of the camera.

I then opened the appeal to page 2 and held it in front of the camera pointing at the screenshot of the Case Details. I started signaling with my fingers 'Two...two...two' and saying 'Page 2...Page 2...Page 2'. It was quite comical, to say the least.

'Mr. Abraham, aapko Hindi samaj mein aatha hai?" Bela Trivedi asked. 

I was clueless as to what this question had to do at all with the whole proceeding. I believe that I wrote the petitions and the appeal in fairly decent English, decent enough to communicate what I wished to say. So, what the Hindi angle to all this was beats me...

"Somebody in the name of the petitioner is appearing virtually. However, we are not in a position to hear him due to connectivity issue...We do not see any illegality or infirmity in the impugned order passed by the Registrar ", Bela Trivedi continued her dictation to the court clerk.

I sat back and watched.

When Bela Trivedi had finished her dictation, Satish Chandra Sharma leaned towards his microphone and addressed the court with a faint smile, saying, "This person has filed a petition that everybody in India should be allowed to smoke a joint."

I smiled. Well, there you go...I could not see the reaction of the esteemed advocates present in the court hall to this statement. 

By now, the judges had moved on to the next item number.

I exited the video call, packed the laptop and left the place. I went back to the laptop shop and returned the hired laptop. They told me that if I had plugged in a headset, my microphone would have been audible. I said that on my existing laptop there was no need to plug in a headset, the microphone was audible without doing that. They said that different computers have different ways of functioning. Well, that was that...I left my laptop with the service center to see if they could make it functional again. When I got back a week later, they said that it was beyond salvaging. They were kind enough to sell me the very same laptop that I had used in the video call for a cheap price that I was able to afford. When I went home and checked by mail, I saw an email from the SCLSC the day prior to the hearing asking me to submit a list of documents to avail of the service of an amicus curiae as an indigent person. I wrote back saying the case had been dismissed. I also emailed the SCLSC the list of documents that they had required.

So, that is how the appeal against the Registrar's order dismissing the special leave petition went. The judges had said in the order related to the hearing on 23rd September - where I was removed from the call - that the hearing on Friday 27th September was a last opportunity for me. Well, I was there...I could be seen, maybe not recognized by the judges, but I could not be heard...As I said earlier, it appears that no matter how lucidly you present your case in writing, finally what you say or do not say in the hearing is what decides your fate...So, if you are a marketing person then you are best suited for in-court proceedings...

Looking back, it seems to me that Bela Trivedi appeared particularly anxious to dismiss the case, seeing the speed with which she started dictating the court order to the bench clerk. Even though my petitions covered the whole spectrum of freeing the ganja plant and the individual, and all aspects - any person growing as much ganja as he or she wished, and using it however he or she wished - to consume, to sell, barter, or use for any purpose that he or she deemed fit, and even though the petitions covered the vast benefits to state and society that legalization would bring, it had been reduced to the simple act of smoking ganja and whether it was to be allowed or not allowed by the moral guardians of society, the adult parents - the judiciary and legislature - who decide what the little children - the citizens - can eat, drink, grow, buy, sell or smoke...If you want ganja for your own well-being, too bad...Make use of the available options of procuring ganja by paying exorbitant money in the black market...That is how we upper classes do it...If not, have some alcohol or tobacco or opioid medications or other synthetic pharmaceutical medications...If you do not like any of these, or if you cannot afford and access any of these, too bad...Suffer your lot because you are the unfortunate...If you die from consuming too much of any of the state-sanctioned poisons, too bad...You should have chosen some other intoxication instead, like the intoxication of power and money which is what we, the upper classes, love the most...

I have included below the appeal against the Registrar's order, the office reports and court orders related to the two hearings for the appeal. So far, I wrote about the three steps I took at the court - the writ petition, the special leave petition and the appeal against the Registrar's order. In the next part, I will cover my learnings and conclusions from this interaction with the apex judiciary of India regarding the violation of fundamental rights due to ganja and charas prohibition...

So folks, that is how things currently stand...Mumma and papa me lords...the Kapoors...will 'not allow' the indigent Siva to smoke his ganja...Kuch samaj mein aaya ki nahi???


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

Koshy T. Abraham ...Petitioner/Appellant

Versus

Union of India ...Respondent

APPLICATION FOR APPEAL AGAINST REGISTRAR ORDER DISMISSING SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) DIARY NO. 3847 OF 2024

To,

Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India and His Companion Judges of the Supreme Court of India.

The Application of the Petitioner most respectfully showeth:

1. The petitioner above named respectfully submits this application seeking to appeal against the judgment/order of the Ld. Registrar of The Supreme Court of India regarding Special Leave Petition (Civil) having Diary No. 3847 of 2024.

2. In the order dated 31-January-2024, the Ld. Registrar dismissed the Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No. 3847 of 2024, under Order VIII, RULE 6(3) AND (4), stating that 'As per the mandate of law Special Leave Petition arises out of an order of High Court/Tribunals/Other subordinate courts vested with judicial powers. This instant special leave petition is not maintainable since the same has been filed following the dismissal of writ petition by this Hon'ble Court.'

3. The petitioner filed the Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No. 3847 of 2024 based on the Disposal Type of the order passed by the Honorable Judges dismissing Writ Petition (Civil) Diary No. 23878 of 2023. The Disposal Type for the order dated 03-October-2023 dismissing the writ petition Diary No. 23878 of 2023 was given as Permission to file SLP/Appeal-allowed and matter dismissed (including all pending Ias). Please refer to the following screenshot of Case Details for Writ Petition (Civil) Diary No. 23878 of 2023 showing Disposal Type.





4. When the petitioner submitted the Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary Number 3847 of 2024 to the Registry, the petition was rejected by the Registry with the defect raised as "WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) Diary No(s). 23878/2023 already dismissed on Date : 03-10-2023, Hence, the filed SLP is not maintainable as challenged the passed by this Hon'ble Court Order. You are requested to file complete and proper petition accordance to SCR. 2013."

5. On going through the Supreme Court Rules (SCR) 2013, the petitioner was unable to find under SCR 2013 PROVISIONS REGARDING SPECIAL LEAVE PETITIONS UNDER ARTICLE 136 OF THE CONSTITUTION, ORDER XXI, SPECIAL LEAVE PETITIONS (CIVIL), or elsewhere in the SCR Rules, a rule which stated that a Special Leave Petition cannot be filed against an order of the Supreme Court. In addition, Article 136 of the Constitution of India states that '136. (1) Notwithstanding anything in this Chapter, the Supreme Court may, in its discretion, grant special leave to appeal from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order in any cause or matter passed or made by any court or tribunal in the territory of India.' It does not state anywhere in Article 136 of the Constitution that special leave cannot be granted against an order by the Supreme Court, rather it states, 'the Supreme Court may, in its discretion, grant special leave to appeal from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order in any cause or matter passed or made by any court or tribunal in the territory of India.' On requesting the Registry to provide further details of the rules referred, the petitioner did not receive any reply.

6. Given the lack of clarification or response from the Registry regarding a rule which states that one cannot file a Special Leave Petition against an order by the Supreme Court, and given the Disposal Type of Writ Petition (Civil) Diary Number 23878 of 2023 as 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal-allowed', the petitioner again submitted the Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary Number 3847 of 2024.

7. The Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary Number 3847 of 2024 was heard by the Ld. Registrar on 31-January-2024 where he issued an order dismissing the Special Leave Petition as not maintainable, as stated in Point 2 above.

8. The order by the Ld. Registrar also states that 'The petitioner, in a manner trying to indulge himself in the second round of litigation, which is a clear abuse of process of law. The petitioner may file appropriate petition as per law as the appropriate remedy lies elsewhere and not in Special Leave Petition. He is in a manner trying to assail the judges of this Court in a writ petition by filing a special leave petition which is not permissable as per law'. Receiving no response from the Registry, in terms of a rule in SCR 2013 which states that one cannot file an SLP/Appeal against a Supreme Court order, and given the fact that the Disposal Type for the writ petition Diary Number 23878/2023 stated 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed', the petitioner filed the Special Leave Petition Diary Number 3847/2024. The petitioner has no intention to abuse the process of law, nor does he wish to assail the judges. The petitioner only wishes to have his fundamental rights - right to life through right to safe intoxicant, right to safe medicine, right to religious freedom, right against discrimination, and right to livelihood – which are critical for a healthy life, restored. He only wishes to pursue the legal routes available for the same, and seeks the intervention of the Supreme Court - as protector of a citizen's fundamental rights with the power to act on the citizen's behalf - in this matter. As this is a matter concerning an individual's fundamental rights, the petitioner had approached the Supreme Court directly with the writ petition, without approaching any of the lower courts.

9. The petitioner seeks a review of the order passed by the Ld. Registrar as he believes that the order is in error, and that the Special Leave Petition (Civil) 3847 of 2024 is not defective as stated by the Ld. Registrar in his order in this regard.


PRAYER:

The petitioner prays that the order of the Ld. Registrar - that the Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No. 3847 of 2024 is not maintainable as per Supreme Court Rules - be reviewed and reconsidered.

Place: Bengaluru
Date: 24-June-2024 
KOSHY T. ABRAHAM
(APPELLANT)


Court Order after first hearing on 23rd September when petitioner was removed from the virtual hearing



Office Report submitted by Registry to Court before second hearing on 27th September 2024




Court Order after second hearing on 27th September 2024







Saturday, 9 November 2024

At the Supreme Court of India for Ganja Legalization: Part II: The Special Leave Petition



When Bela Trivedi opened the hearing on October 3, 2023, for the Writ Petition Diary Number 23878 of 2023 in Court 6 as Item 12 saying, "Let us warn you, you have two choices - dismissal of the case or imposition of costs", I misunderstood her. I understood the second choice of this catch 22 statement as meaning that I would need to be willing to bear the costs of conducting the case for ganja and charas legalization as per my writ petition in the Supreme Court of India. I was totally clueless as to the subject matter value of the case. Yes, I had written in the writ petition that legalizing ganja and charas in India could be beneficial to the country to the tune of Rs 25 lakh crores. But I had no idea how much the cost of conducting a trial would be, in which the respondent was the Revenue Secretary of the Department of Revenue under the Finance Ministry of the Indian government. In my mind, the costs I envisioned involved this person flying to Delhi, staying in five-star hotels and having lavish parties for which the bills would be submitted in the court, and I would be required to foot the bill. I had barely enough money in my bank account to finance my trip to New Delhi and attend the hearing, so paying for the cost of the trial was totally out of the question. This - besides the hostility of Bela Trivedi's opening statement - is what made me speechless and pause for a few moments before I spoke. It was only much later, when I saw Bela Trivedi imposing costs on various petitioners that I understood she actually meant that she would fine me when she said, "imposition of costs".

As I said in Part 1, when I went back to the hotel in the evening after the hearing of the writ petition on October 3rd, 2023  and checked the Case Details on the Supreme Court website, the court order had not yet been uploaded, but the Status/Stage and Disposal Type fields for the writ petition said 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed'. Based on my misunderstanding of what Bela Trivedi said, and seeing the Disposal Type for the writ petition as 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed', I decided - on the two-and-a-half day train journey back to Bengaluru from New Delhi - that I would file a special leave petition (SLP) stating that I could not afford to bear the costs of conducting the trial, and that I did not even know what such costs would amount to.



As soon as I was back in Bengaluru, I checked the Supreme Court website for the court order. The court order had been uploaded but on opening it I found that it only said that "We do not find any reason to entertain this petition filed under Article 32 of the Constitution of India. The present petition is, accordingly, dismissed."



There was no mention in the court order of the "Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed" statement that appeared in the Status/Stage and Disposal Type fields of the Case Details on the Supreme Court website. Now, whether the statement "Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed" made in the Status/Stage and Disposal Type fields of the Case Details was an addition by somebody, or its absence in the Court Order was an omission made by somebody, and whether this was willfully done, or in error, is a mystery that only the Supreme Court of India can solve.

For me, the path was clear. The Status/Stage and Disposal Type fields in the Case Details on the Supreme Court website said, 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed' and so I started working on a special leave petition (SLP). I worked on this for about two weeks. I stated in the special leave petition (which is included at the end of this article along with the subsequent order) that I had been unable to gauge the cost of the subject matter and so I had remained silent when Bela Trivedi presented me with the two choices of dismissal or costs. I also stated in the SLP that I was an indigent person with no income for the past 14 years, barring a brief period of employment for about 7 months in between. I provided details of my possessions, my expenses, and included my bank statements for the preceding two years. I stated that I had devoted the last six years to researching this matter, and that I had prepared the writ petition through about three months of work, had traveled to New Delhi at my own cost, and had generally put in a lot of time and effort into the matter already, so asking me to also bear the burden of costs for conducting the trial was unfair. I stated that given my current bank balance, I could afford to pay no more than Rs 5000 towards the cost of conducting the case.

In addition to the statements in the special leave petition regarding my financial status, I stated that this case was of great significance to India since it involved the fundamental rights violations of hundreds of millions of the poorest Indians. I stated that there were vast economic, social, environmental, healthcare and legal benefits that ganja and charas legalization would bring for India. I also stated that this was probably the most important case in the Supreme Court of India's history and would be a landmark case like no other.

Once I had prepared the special leave petition, I filed it in the last week of October in the new Supreme Court e-Filing website now available after the old one had been migrated and decommissioned. I got a response from the Supreme Court Registry the very next day itself. The Registry rejected the special leave petition stating that it was not maintainable since I had filed a petition challenging the order of the Supreme Court. Thinking that there were issues with the format in which I had filed the SLP - I had filed it as a single file - I broke it into separate files that map to the index and re-filed it. This was again rejected by the Registry with the same reason cited as in the previous case. I wrote to e-Filing a couple of times asking the reason for why the special leave petition was not maintainable, especially given the Status/Stage and Disposal Type fields stating 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed' but got no response. So, I submitted the petition again. This time the reason for rejection was slightly modified. It still said that the petition was not maintainable since I was challenging an order by the Supreme Court. But it also said that I was "requested to file complete and proper petition accordance to SCR. 2013."

On going through the Supreme Court Rules 2013 - PROVISIONS REGARDING SPECIAL LEAVE PETITIONS UNDER ARTICLE 136 OF THE CONSTITUTION, ORDER XXI, SPECIAL LEAVE PETITIONS (CIVIL), I did not come across any rule that stated I could not file a special leave petition against an order by the Supreme Court.

Further, according to the Supreme Court of India Handbook on Practice and Procedure and Office Procedure 2017, Chapter III CLASSIFICATION OF CASES, it states that - "8. Petition for Special Leave to Appeal – A petition filed under Article 136 of the Constitution from an order of the High Court refusing to grant certificate under Article 134A of the Constitution or in any other case from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order passed or made by any Court or Tribunal, except relating to armed forces.  It may be either civil or criminal." Here the statement "or in any other case from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order passed or made by any Court or Tribunal, except relating to armed forces" surely also meant that I could appeal against an order by the Supreme Court Original Jurisdiction, especially when the court itself had given me permission to file an SLP/Appeal.

So, I intimated the Registry, asking them to clarify which SCR 2013 rules I needed to refer to. I did not receive this clarification. Instead, I was directed by one section in the Registry to contact another section in the Registry as the matter was not fresh. On requesting who the concerned section would be, I received no immediate response. In the meantime, I refiled the SLP after changing the jurisdiction in it from Appellate Jurisdiction to Extra-Ordinary Appellate Jurisdiction, thinking that there may be an issue with the jurisdiction under which I had filed the SLP. The Registry replied to my previous email stating that I was to contact the Public Interest Litigation - Writ (PIL-W) section. I replied stating that I did not wish to submit a PIL-W, and that I wished to submit the SLP that the judges had given me permission to file. The Registry rejected the submitted SLP with the same reasons as before. I again wrote asking the same questions but replied no answer regarding which Supreme Court Rules they were referring to, and why the SLP was not maintainable. I received no response for about four weeks. Finally in the first week of January 2024, I emailed the Registry asking to know if the repeated rejection of my SLP had anything to do with my refusal earlier in my writ petition to accept a Supreme Court appointed advocate or amicus curiae. I said that the limitation period for filing the SLP of 90 days was nearly over now due to the delays, and that I was amenable to a Supreme Court appointed advocate or amicus curiae if that was the reason for the repeated rejection of my SLP. In response to this email, I was asked to contact another section in the Registry. This is the classic situation being played out in the Supreme Court of a person being sent from department to department - like a pinball in a pinball machine - that is usually played out in government offices. All this was happening against the backdrop of a time limitation set on filing petitions. Delays that happen from the Registry in responding, finally require the petitioner to file an application condoning delay, thus adding to the workload of all concerned. 

Finally, in the last week of January 2024 I saw the case status of the special leave petition on the e-Filing website change from 'Pending Acceptance' to 'Pending Scrutiny'. It was assigned a Diary Number - 3847 of 2024. This essentially meant that the Registry had processed the petition and that it was ready for scrutiny at the next stage. I kept checking the new e-filing site from January till April and did not see any change in status. The status of the SLP in the e-Filing site remained as 'Pending Scrutiny'. In April, I thought of checking the main Supreme Court site in addition to the e-Filing site and found in the Case Details for SLP 3847 of 2024 that the case status showed as 'Disposed' with the Disposal Type as 'Lodged'. Thinking that 'Lodged' meant that the matter was now ready to be placed before the judges after the Registry had processed it, I waited for a few more weeks to see if there was any change. Seeing no updates, I wrote to the Registry in the third week of May asking what this status and disposal type meant. The Registry wrote back to me the next day with a copy of an order by the Registrar dated 31st January 2024 attached. 

When I went through the Registrar's order, I found that he had disposed the special leave petition Diary No. 3847 of 2024 on 31st January 2024, stating "As per the mandate of law Special Leave Petition arises out of an order of High Court/Tribunals/other subordinate courts vested with judicial powers. The instant leave petition is not maintainable since the same has been filed following the dismissal of writ petition by this Hon'ble Court. The petitioner, in a manner trying to indulge himself in that second round of litigation which is a clear abuse of process of law. The petitioner may file appropriate petition as per law as the appropriate remedy lies elsewhere and not in the form of Special Leave Petition. He is in a manner trying to assail the judges of this Court in a writ petition by filing a special leave petition which is not permissible as per law." He further stated in his order that "In these circumstances, I am of the view that this is a fit case which attracts Order XV Rule 5 of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013. and entails non-registration. Accordingly, I hereby, decline to receive and register the present petition as it does not disclose any reasonable cause under Order XV Rule 5 of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013."

So, the Registrar had dismissed the special leave petition citing the same reasons that the Registry had given. There was no response as to which Supreme Court Rules stated that one could not file a special leave petition against a Supreme Court Order. There was also no response as to why the Status/Stage and Disposal Type fields in the Case Details for the writ petition Diary No. 23878 of 2023 stated 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed'. There was no response as to why this particular statement was present in the Case Details on the Supreme Court website and missing from the court order, and as to which of these two presentations of facts was in error. As I said earlier, the sole reason why I went down the special leave petition path was because of the statement 'Permission to file SLP/Appeal allowed'. Otherwise, I would have filed a Review Petition against the Supreme Court's order dismission my writ petition Diary Number 23878 of 2023 in October 2023 but now the limitation period for filing a review has passed.

In the meantime, South Africa, whose Constitutional Court had ruled that cannabis prohibition was a violation of the constitutional rights of the individual a few years back, legalized cannabis for adult recreational use around April 2024 with its legislature finally acting on the order of the court. Germany, the biggest importer of medical cannabis till 2024, also legalized cannabis for adult recreational use in April with permission for home growing of up to three plants per household and permission for citizens to create cannabis growing clubs where up to 100 persons could pool in their resources and grow cannabis to meet their collective consumption needs. The reasons cited by the German Health Minister Karl Lauterbach for legalizing cannabis for adult recreational use were reduction of crime and protecting the youth. Both these are real benefits of cannabis legalization, as Canada has shown with dropping youth usage rates (as have the US states of Washington and Colorado) and the overtaking of black market sales in Canada by legal sales within two years of federal legalization. The unstated reason is probably that the German medical cannabis market was finding it difficult to procure cannabis from Canada, the Netherlands, Denmark and Israel at the quantities and prices that it desired, given the demand surge across Europe, Asia and Oceania for medical cannabis and the shortage of medical cannabis exporting countries. Medical cannabis is, as I stated in various places, basically the elites of various nations consuming cannabis and calling it medicine, while when the poor classes of society - who are the traditional users for its medical and intoxicating properties - consume it, it becomes the illegal drug, ganja. Mexico, whose Supreme Court, like South Africa's Constitutional Court, also ruled that cannabis prohibition was a violation of fundamental rights of the individual a few years back, has not yet legalized cannabis for recreational use through legislature. The reasons for the delay by Mexico's legislature are quite obvious. Mexico is the main source of heroin, cocaine and methamphetamine for the US of A, and the Mexican cartels work closely with politicians and drug enforcement within Mexico and across the border in the USA to delay federal cannabis legalization in both countries as long as possible.

While all this was happening elsewhere, here in India - the land of Siva and his divine herb, ganja, the land that is unquestionably the greatest cannabis nation in the world - the judiciary was using technicalities and other tactics to shirk its primary responsibility of correcting the fundamental rights violations against the citizen that has been going on now for 150 years.

I was seething once again as I pondered my next steps.

I am including the Special Leave Petition Diary No 3847 of 2024 and the subsequent order by the Registrar below. The intent of posting these documents here is the same as it was with the writ petition. It is to share my experience at the Supreme Court in this matter, and to aid and encourage other citizens to take proactive action through judicial activism to correct this violation of fundamental rights that cannabis prohibition entails, especially for the poorest classes, the indigenous communities, aboriginal tribes and the outcasts (the class that I consider myself to be a part of) ...


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
[S.C.R., Order XXI Rule 3(1)(a)]


CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION S.L.P. (Civil) No 3847 of 2024


BETWEEN

Petitioner: Koshy T. Abraham

Vs

Respondent: Union of India, Through Secretary (Revenue),
Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance
128 A, North Block, New Delhi-110001
Ph: 011–23092653, 011-2309211
Email: rsecy@nic.in

(Under Article 136 of the Constitution of India)


To,

Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India and His Companion Judges of the Supreme Court of India.

The Special Leave Petition of the Petitioner most respectfully showeth:


1. The petitioner above named respectfully submits this petition seeking special leave to appeal against the judgment/order of The Supreme Court of India regarding Writ Petition (Civil) having Diary No. 23878/2023 and Case No. 001106/2023. 

In the hearing on 03-October-2023 in Court No. 6 as Item No. 12 of the writ petition Diary No.23878/2023, filed by the petitioner Koshy T. Abraham, the Honorable Judges gave the petitioner a choice of dismissal of the case or the conducting of the case at cost to be borne by the petitioner.

Due to the petitioner's personal financial considerations, that were unstated by him at the time of the hearing, as well as his not being able to associate a value to the potential financial cost of conducting the case, the petitioner was unable to agree to the bearing of costs arising from the case. The Honorable Judges, therefore, dismissed the writ petition Diary No. 23878/2023 on 03-October 2023, with permission for the petitioner to file a Special Leave Petition/Appeal.

This Special Leave Petition, is subsequently being filed by the petitioner of Writ Petition (Civil) with Diary No. 23878/2023 and Case No. 001106/2023 seeking special leave to appeal against the order by The Supreme Court of India, Original Jurisdiction, on 03-October-2023, dismissing the writ petition.


2. QUESTIONS OF LAW:

The following questions of the law arise for consideration by this Hon’ble Court:

The petitioner filed Writ Petition (Civil) Diary No. 23878/2023, seeking the issuance of a mandamus writ by the Supreme Court of India to the respondent for the removal of the word 'cannabis' and all its other names – ganja, charas/hashish, bhang, THC – from the NDPS Act of 1985, as this infringes on the fundamental rights of the petitioner, as well as hundreds of millions of Indian citizens like him.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, stated that ganja was, until the 19th century, one of India's foremost natural medicines, one of India's safest and widely used intoxicants, one of India's foremost entheogens and one of India's most important agricultural crops. Ganja was, especially, the intoxicant, the medicine, the entheogen and a key source of income for India's poorest persons - including the lowest classes and castes, the indigenous communities, the religious mendicants and the bulk of Indian farmers, who were small and marginal farmers. This is detailed in the section Facts of the Case, as well as supported by various Annexures, in the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, stated that with the prohibition of ganja and charas, his following rights have been violated: his right to one of India's foremost natural medicines; his right to one of India's safest intoxicants; his right to one of India's foremost entheogens; his right to one of India's most important agricultural crops that formed a key source of income for the small farmer in the past; his right to equality; and his right against discrimination. The petitioner, in his writ petition, stated that his rights have been violated under Articles 14, 15, 19, 21, 25, 38, 43, 46 and 47 of the Constitution of India. This is detailed in the section Questions of Law of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, stated that the dangers of harmful intoxicants, like alcohol and tobacco, as well as the use of synthetic pharmaceutical medicines, were causing widespread damage to Indian society, in the absence of ganja as safe intoxicant and affordable, accessible natural medicine. This is detailed in the section Facts of the Case of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, stated that ganja, despite prohibition, is widely available through the black market, and is mainly accessed by the upper classes who have the means to afford the prohibited herb, and influence over law enforcement to escape legal action, whereas an indigent individual does not have access to the herb, cannot afford the price in the black market, and most often faces more law enforcement action compared to the upper classes. This is detailed in the section Questions of Law of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, stated that he does not wish to consume the harmful legal State-sanctioned intoxicants – alcohol and tobacco, nor does he wish to consume the synthetic pharmaceutical medications that the State provides to the citizen as medicine. The petitioner also does not wish to follow the religious practices of the orthodoxy and religious organizations, but wishes to practice direct communion with the eternal spirit through the use of ganja as entheogen, as has been the spiritual practice for thousands of years in India by hundreds of millions of persons. The petitioner also does not wish to break the laws by procuring ganja from the black market, if he could afford it that is, nor does he wish to break the laws by cultivating ganja which is currently illegal, as per the NDPS Act of 1985. This is detailed in the section Questions of Law of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his petition, stated that he wished to lead a simple, minimalistic life with the use of ganja as natural medicine, the use of ganja as safe natural intoxicant, the cultivation/homegrowing of ganja for personal use, and the use of ganja for spiritual purposes. This is detailed in the section Questions of Law of the writ petition.


3. DECLARATION IN TERMS OF RULE 3(2):

The petitioner states that no other petition seeking leave to appeal has been filed by him against the impugned judgment and order.


4. DECLARATION IN TERMS OF RULE 5:

The Annexures produced alongwith the SLP are true copies of the pleadings/documents which formed part of the records of the case in the Court/Tribunal below against whose order the leave to appeal is sought for in this petition.


5. GROUNDS:

Leave to appeal is sought for on the following grounds.

The petitioner, in his pursuit of a simple, minimalistic, spiritual life resigned from his job in the software industry in June 2010. He only took up one salaried job subsequently, as an IT consultant on contract, for a period of 7 months in September 2013. The desire to move away from the pursuit of money, and to live a sustainable life where he is free to pursue what he perceives to be the most important things in life, and to be his own master, were key factors in his decision to not work for money or for any organization.

The petitioner has, in the last thirteen years, with the exception of the contract job between September 2013 and April 2014, lived mainly off his savings. Some of the measures taken in this period to live the minimalistic life, free from the subjugation to money, have been: ceasing to purchase new clothes; not purchasing a smartphone but instead using the cheapest available feature phone in the market; using the same laptop purchased ten years ago; sparingly using the same car purchased 17 years ago; sparingly using the same motorcycle purchased 25 years ago; smoking beedis; drastically cutting down the consumption of alcohol; drastically cutting down eating and drinking in commercial establishments; walking and using public transport where feasible; taking up small-scale farming on the small piece of land that he inherited from his father, etc.

The petitioner, in the course of the last decade of pursuing minimalism and simple living, has become part of the poorer classes in Indian society today based on his fast-depleting savings and bank balance. The petitioner spent money in the range of Rs. 30,000 a month on an average, looking at the last two years. The main source of this money was the savings from his life as an employed person more than a decade ago.

Most of this money was spent on essentials like food, fuel, buying medicines for his aged mother, buying food and provisions, maintenance of motorcar and motorcycle, and paying various household bills such as water, telephone, house tax, etc. At the time of preparing this petition, the petitioner has a bank balance of Rs. 69,300. Please refer to Annexure SLP2: Bank Statements for the past two years for more information. The average monthly bank balance of the petitioner over the last two years has been Rs. 16,419. Please refer to Annexure SLP3: Average Monthly Bank Balance Based on Bank Statement for last two years.

By not taking up a salaried job, and not working for organizations, the petitioner has been able to focus the last six years of his life on researching and writing about the cannabis plant and its prohibition. Not working for money, and not being married and having to raise a family, has enabled the petitioner to dedicate his time, without being biased or coerced by financial or social considerations, towards this most important and fundamental issue of cannabis prohibition. One of the outputs of his efforts over the last six years is his blog – Thoughts from the void, https://ravingkoshy.blogspot.com. Another is the writ petition Diary No. 23878/2023 that was filed in the Supreme Court of India. The petitioner has taken this path, not just for the restoration of his own fundamental rights, but also for the restoration of the fundamental rights of the most vulnerable sections of Indian society, for the protection of the precious cannabis plant, and for the well-being of this nation as a whole.

The petitioner states here that, in terms of his possessions and entitlements, are the following:

  • A house, on land of 22.5 cents, in Kerala that he inherited from his father. This is his ancestral home, handed down over eight generations. The current value of this house and land is something that the petitioner has not ascertained, and does not wish to do so. The petitioner sees himself as the guardian of this ancestral home, and does not wish to place this as bank guarantee or surety in the matter of this case.
  • A motorcar, a Scorpio Dlx 2.6 2006 model SUV, that the petitioner purchased 17 years ago when he was employed. The petitioner is unable to ascertain the current market value of this motorcar.
  • A motorcycle, a Yezdi Roadking 250cc 1994 model, that was purchased 25 years ago. The petitioner is unable to ascertain the current market value of this motorcycle.
  • A bank balance of Rs. 69,300 at the time when the petitioner began preparing this petition.
  • A monthly pension of Rs. 1,077 from LIC as a result of the gratuity paid by his former employer.

The petitioner, states in his writ petition, that ganja was once the medicine, intoxicant, entheogen and means of livelihood for India poorest classes, including the labouring and working classes, indigenous communities and religious mendicants, who together constituted the majority of the Indian population, and still do so. This is detailed in the section Facts of the Case in the writ petition. He has supported these facts with evidence as found in the Annexures to the writ petition.

The petitioner, states in his writ petition, that he wishes to use ganja as safe intoxicant rather than alcohol or tobacco; that he wishes to use ganja as medicine – for relief from stress, anxiety, fatigue, pain, to improve digestion, sleep, ward off infectious diseases, for treating wounds, and as a tonic as he approaches old age; that he wishes to use ganja as an entheogen for his spiritual practices of yoga, meditation, and focusing on the eternal spirit; that he wishes to grow ganja for his personal use, or to share, barter or trade with whoever he wishes just like any other agricultural commodity. This is detailed in the section Questions of Law in the writ petition.

The petitioner, states in his writ petition, that his own right to ganja as safe intoxicant, ganja as most potent natural medicine, ganja as India's foremost entheogen, and ganja as a means to raise one's standard of living through cultivation, sharing, bartering or selling have been directly affected by the prohibition of ganja. This infringes on his right to good health, right to practice religion, right to equality, right against discrimination, and right to practice an occupation that was once recognized as one of India's most significant and sustainable occupations. All these fundamental rights are covered under Articles 14, 15, 19, 21, 25, 38, 43, 46 and 47 of the Constitution of India. This is detailed in the section Questions of Law in the writ petition.

The petitioner, states in his writ petition, that the legalization of ganja and charas has the potential for the State to earn additional revenue that will be sufficient to wipe out India's entire current fiscal deficit, with money to spare for critical areas that need focus such as education, health and protection of the environment. This is detailed in the section Grounds of the writ petition.

The petition, in his writ petition, states that ganja as natural medicine can help India achieve its goals of affordable universal health care, especially for India's poorest persons who form the majority of this country's population. The current scenario of expensive, harmful and inaccessible synthetic pharmaceutical drugs is not sustainable for a majority of the Indian population. This is detailed in the section Grounds of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, states that ganja as safe intoxicant can greatly negate the harms caused to Indian society by alcohol, tobacco and illegal synthetic drugs. Ganja, when it was legal in the past, was primarily the intoxicant of the poorest persons in Indian society. With legalization, these sections of society can once more have access to safe, affordable and medicinal ganja as intoxicant. The legalization of ganja and charas will greatly reduce the harms to Indian society caused by tobacco, alcohol, opioids and abuse of legal and illegal synthetic pharmaceutical medications, and the resulting costs to public health. This is detailed in the section Grounds of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, states that ganja was India's foremost entheogen or aid to spirituality. It was used by persons across multiple religions for their direct communion with the gods that they worshipped. The prohibition of ganja has greatly interfered with their religious practices, including the petitioner's. The legalization of ganja will enable vast numbers of India's citizens, across religions, to pursue their religion and spirituality, without being forced to submit to the religious institutions that serve to play broker between man and god. This is detailed in the section Grounds of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his petition, states that the legalization of ganja will enable the optimization of law enforcement, excise, judiciary and prison systems to focus on violent and financial crimes that require most attention. It will shrink the black market for illegal drugs that is now becoming increasingly sophisticated and organized. This is detailed in the section Grounds of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, states that the legalization of ganja will enable the small farmer to cultivate and sell a crop that was once a key agricultural crop in India, thus raising his income and standard of living. This will have a significant positive impact on the Indian economy as the majority of farmers in India are small-scale farmers. The export of much sought after indigenous varieties of Indian ganja globally will easily become one of India's key export items, enabling the reduction of trade deficits with a sustainable, renewable agricultural crop. This is detailed in the section Grounds of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, states that the legalization of ganja will energize research in the country, and spawn numerous sustainable and ecofriendly industries, such as fibres, textiles, biodegradable plastics, biofuels, construction material, animal feed, food and beverages, wellness, retail, pulp and paper, small scale industries, etc. These industries will boost the Indian economy and counter the effects of climate change brought about by the industries that thrive in the absence of ganja - petrochemicals, fossil fuels, synthetic pharmaceuticals – legal and illegal, timber, opioids, alcohol, tobacco and cotton. The new sustainable cannabis-based industries will provide employment for vast numbers of Indian citizens. This is detailed in the section Grounds of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, states the legalization of ganja will enable India's indigenous communities to practice sustainable living as they did for thousands of years before ganja prohibition. It will reinstate these communities as guardians and propagators of cannabis biodiversity. It will provide India's indigenous communities with a means to raise their income, standard of living, health, and help to vastly reduce the discrimination that they face on account of their social, economic and caste status. This is detailed in the section Grounds of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, states that the legalization of ganja will have profoundly beneficial implications for the environment. It will help to sequester carbon, enrich depleted soils, use less water and fertilizers for agriculture, create sustainable industries that meet the goals of a circular economy, enable the cultivation of a much more sustainable crop than paddy, cotton, maize or tobacco, provide fodder for domesticated animals, and vastly benefit animal, bird and bee populations. It will be a potent weapon to combat climate change and negate the harms of the petrochemical, fossil fuel, synthetic pharmaceutical, opioid, alcohol and tobacco industries. This is detailed in the section Grounds of the writ petition.

The petitioner, in his writ petition, states that no other plant has been discriminated against as much as the ganja plant has been. The plant that is widely acknowledged as the beloved herb of the great god, Siva, has been destroyed on massive scales since regulation and prohibition began in the 19th century in India. Many precious varieties of ganja - with vast medicinal and industrial properties – are likely to have become extinct. Wherever a ganja plant is found growing, it has been exterminated. The biodiversity of this most valuable plant is under great threat with the continuing discrimination. This is detailed in the section Questions of Law in the writ petition.

The petitioner states here that the legalization of ganja will be among the most important, and far-reaching rulings, made in the history of the Supreme Court of India as custodian of fundamental rights. This will truly restore the rights of vast numbers of India's poorest populations, including the indigenous communities, lower classes and castes, working and labouring classes, its spiritual mendicants, its hundreds of millions suffering from lack of medicine that works, its elderly, and its persons suffering from addictions to various kinds of harmful substances. It will be a big step in ensuring equality, liberty, fraternity and justice – social, economic and political. Besides restoring the rights of Indian citizens, the ruling will be a significant step in the protection of the cannabis plant, which currently faces extermination on massive scales, as well as danger of extinction of many precious cannabis varieties endemic to India. The implications of this ruling will not only be felt across the length and breadth of this country for all time to come, it will also have great positive consequences for many nations across the world. The ruling will be a significant step in not just India's, but the also world's, attempts to combat human-induced climate change.


6. MAIN PRAYER:

The petitioner prays that considering the following:

  • His inability to arrive at a financial valuation of the amount or value of the subject-matter of the case,
  • The time and resources he has put in to bring the subject-matter of the writ petition this far, including: more than six years of research; three months to prepare the petition; traveling to New Delhi, at own cost, to appear for the court hearing; bearing the cost of the writ petition and this special leave petition
  • The petitioner's current financial position and inability to pay the further costs of conducting the case, if it were to be anything above Rs. 5,000/-
  • The vast benefits that the State and Indian society would derive from the legalization of ganja and charas
  • The violation of rights, because of ganja prohibition, of hundreds of millions of Indian citizens, including the petitioner, to safe, accessible and affordable medicine, intoxicant, entheogen and sustainable living,

the decision of the Honorable Court to impose the further costs of conducting the case solely on the petitioner, with regard to Writ Petition (Civil) Diary No, 23878/2023, be reconsidered in the context of the importance of the case.

The petitioner, therefore, prays that the honorable judges of the Supreme Court exempt him from paying further costs for conducting the case, if the same exceeds Rs. 5000/-.

Place: Bengaluru
Date: 20-October-2023 
KOSHY T. ABRAHAM
(PETITIONER-IN-PERSON)


Registrar's Order Dated 31st January 2024 Dismissing Special Leave Petition 3847 of 2024